Daily Debate results: Was Max Holloway vs. Frankie Edgar the right fight to make?

Frankie Edgar is unquestionably a future UFC Hall of Famer, but is he the current top contender in the featherweight division?

It’s an interesting question. After all, Edgar (23-6-1 MMA, 17-6-1 UFC) is a former champion and one of the most respected athletes in the history of the sport. And perhaps most importantly, he had a title shot lined up against champ Max Holloway (20-4 MMA, 16-4 UFC) one year ago but agreed to put the opportunity aside to face then-undefeated Brian Ortega at UFC 222 in a clash the promotion needed to help save that March 2018 event when “Blessed” was forced off the card.

Edgar lost that fight, and Ortega went on to face Holloway. “The Answer” then rebounded with a decision win over Cub Swanson.

In the meantime, Alexander Volkanovski (20-1 MMA, 7-0 UFC) has been making quite the case that he’s the rightful No. 1 contender.

Since Edgar was last in action, Alexander “The Great” has picked up wins over the gritty Darren Elkins, perennial contender Chad Mendes and perhaps the greatest featherweight of all-time, Jose Aldo. Yet just a few days after Volkanovski’s latest win, UFC officials their plans for Holloway vs. Edgar. Was that the right decision?

That was the question we asked in our latest MMA Junkie Radio Daily Debate.

The results, via Twitter:

To hear the MMA Junkie Radio crew weigh in on the topic, watch the video above.

For the latest on UFC 240, check out the UFC Rumors section of the site.

MMA Junkie Radio broadcasts Monday-Friday at 8 p.m. ET (5 p.m. PT) live from Mandalay Bay Resort & Casino’s Race & Sports Book. The show is hosted by “Gorgeous” George Garcia, Brian “Goze” Garcia and Dan Tom. For more information or to download past episodes, go to www.mmajunkie.com/radio. You can also check out www.siriusxm.com/siriusxmfightnation.

1 week ago

Your Ad could be here please email () us for the details.

email us »


Latest news in MMA

UFC cuts heavyweight Justin Willis
18 hours ago
Conor McGregor says he injured left hand from training too hard
18 hours ago
Donald Cerrone details frustration in booking Tony Ferguson for UFC 238, expects title shot after
19 hours ago
Conor McGregor injures arm, vows to ‘push on’
19 hours ago
Stream or download MMA Junkie Radio #2926 with Nick Newell, Aljamain Sterling
19 hours ago
Sage Northcutt wants to know how you think he looks
20 hours ago
Examining the future of MMA for women
20 hours ago
Rashad Evans: Jon Jones vs. Daniel Cormier would be ‘a totally different fight’ at heavyweight
21 hours ago
Colby Covington calls ‘fake news’ on Kamaru Usman surgery
21 hours ago
Colby Covington visits Donald Trump's sons at Trump Tower
21 hours ago
Tyron Woodley details lesson he learned from Jon Jones
21 hours ago
Conor McGregor makes case for Floyd Mayweather rematch
22 hours ago
PHOTO | UFC’s Colby Covington reunites with the Trump family
22 hours ago
Jim Ross discusses legacies of Brock Lesnar, Ronda Rousey
22 hours ago
Khabib Nurmagomedov gets into the fight promotion business
22 hours ago
Ian Heinisch responds to Antonio Carlos Junior's foul complaints: 'He was just breaking mentally'
22 hours ago
Potential opponents for Zebaztian Kadestam
22 hours ago
Joe Rogan reacts to Sage Northcutt losing to Cosmo Alexandre
23 hours ago
What's a champ-champ to do next? Bellator's Patricio Freire has a few ideas
1 day ago
Miesha Tate says ONE Championship is ‘far from minor league’
1 day ago