Daily Debate results: Was Max Holloway vs. Frankie Edgar the right fight to make?

Frankie Edgar is unquestionably a future UFC Hall of Famer, but is he the current top contender in the featherweight division?

It’s an interesting question. After all, Edgar (23-6-1 MMA, 17-6-1 UFC) is a former champion and one of the most respected athletes in the history of the sport. And perhaps most importantly, he had a title shot lined up against champ Max Holloway (20-4 MMA, 16-4 UFC) one year ago but agreed to put the opportunity aside to face then-undefeated Brian Ortega at UFC 222 in a clash the promotion needed to help save that March 2018 event when “Blessed” was forced off the card.

Edgar lost that fight, and Ortega went on to face Holloway. “The Answer” then rebounded with a decision win over Cub Swanson.

In the meantime, Alexander Volkanovski (20-1 MMA, 7-0 UFC) has been making quite the case that he’s the rightful No. 1 contender.

Since Edgar was last in action, Alexander “The Great” has picked up wins over the gritty Darren Elkins, perennial contender Chad Mendes and perhaps the greatest featherweight of all-time, Jose Aldo. Yet just a few days after Volkanovski’s latest win, UFC officials their plans for Holloway vs. Edgar. Was that the right decision?

That was the question we asked in our latest MMA Junkie Radio Daily Debate.

The results, via Twitter:

To hear the MMA Junkie Radio crew weigh in on the topic, watch the video above.

For the latest on UFC 240, check out the UFC Rumors section of the site.

MMA Junkie Radio broadcasts Monday-Friday at 8 p.m. ET (5 p.m. PT) live from Mandalay Bay Resort & Casino’s Race & Sports Book. The show is hosted by “Gorgeous” George Garcia, Brian “Goze” Garcia and Dan Tom. For more information or to download past episodes, go to www.mmajunkie.com/radio. You can also check out www.siriusxm.com/siriusxmfightnation.

3 months ago

Your Ad could be here please email () us for the details.

email us »


Latest news in MMA

Casey Kenney seeks matchups with 'legends' Urijah Faber, Frankie Edgar after UFC 241
35 minutes ago
Friends Devonte Smith, Khama Worthy wrap brains around fighting each other at UFC 241
1 hour ago
11 times Nate Diaz gave zero (expletives)
2 hours ago
UFC 241 play-by-play and live results (6:15 p.m. ET)
2 hours ago
UFC 241 discussion thread
2 hours ago
Video: Watch UFC 241 post-event press conference on MMA Junkie
2 hours ago
UFC 241 live streaming commentary with MMA Junkie Radio on SportsCastr
6 hours ago
UFC 241 preview with Chael Sonnen: What to expect from Cormier-Miocic, Diaz-Pettis, more
10 hours ago
Ex-UFC champ Cody Garbrandt schedules surgery, sidelined until early 2020
10 hours ago
UFC 241 breakdown: Can Paulo Costa earn a career-making win over Yoel Romero?
11 hours ago
Israel Adesanya on road to gold: From sitting in nose bleeds to making noses bleed
11 hours ago
Dual UFC champ Henry Cejudo adds Jose Aldo to hit list, teases next fight announcement
12 hours ago
UFC 241 weigh-ins faceoffs video highlights, photos
13 hours ago
Photos: UFC 241 ceremonial weigh-ins
13 hours ago
Nate Diaz in one word: What UFC fighters think of Stockton's finest
14 hours ago
Dana Cam reveals intense UFC 241 staredowns
14 hours ago
UFC 241 weigh-ins faceoff: Anthony Pettis, Nate Diaz finally across from each other
15 hours ago
UFC 241 weigh-ins faceoff: Daniel Cormier, Stipe Miocic get up close
15 hours ago
Eager to return, Anthony Smith dishes on Corey Anderson, Jon Jones and Chris Weidman
16 hours ago
Brandon Davis hesitated on taking UFC 241 fight due to California's rehydration rules
17 hours ago